Saturday, January 23, 2016

Same sex attraction — A Darwinian paradox, no more

Like most human behavioural traits, a preference for same-sex sexual relationships can be informed in part by learning and environmental / developmental experiences.  A role for genes is also now abundantly clear.  So-called ‘gay genes’ have not yet been precisely identified, but pedigree and twin studies have shown that homosexuality tends to run in families (reviewed in Ngun etal. 2011), and a recent genetic analysis of 409 pairs of gay brothers links sexual orientation in men with particular regions of the human genome (Sanders et al. 2015).  The pressing question then — described often as a ‘Darwinian paradox’ — is how do we account for the common occurrence of homosexuality in evolutionary terms, given that it would seem to present a severe limitation on evolutionary fitness through one’s direct lineage? Several explanations and speculations have been offered (see the very accessible review in Barash 2012) — and many illustrate, as the saying goes: ‘things are not always as they seem’.

For male homosexuality, one of the best explanations so far comes from recent studies suggesting that female relatives of gay men generally have more offspring than the female relatives of straight men.   In other words, there are genetic factors transmitted through the maternal line (partly linked to the X-chromosome) that increase the probability of becoming homosexual in males, but they promote higher fecundity in females (Camperio-Ciani et al. 2004, Iemmola and Camperio-Ciani 2009).  Hence, the genetic factors that “… influence homosexual orientation in males are not selected against because they increase fecundity in female carriers, thus offering a solution to the Darwinian paradox and an explanation of why natural selection does not progressively eliminate homosexuals” (Iemmola and Camperio-Ciani 2009).


A similar hypothesis (that applies to either male or female homosexuality) is suggested by Zietsch et al. (2008):

“The genes influencing homosexuality have two effects.  First, and most obviously, these genes increase the risk for homosexuality, which ostensibly has decreased Darwinian fitness.  Countervailing this, however, these same genes appear to increase sex-atypical gender identity, which our results suggest may increase mating success in heterosexuals. This mechanism, called antagonistic pleiotropy, might maintain genes that increase the risk for homosexuality because they increase the number of sex partners in the relatives of homosexuals.” … “The traits most reliably associated with homosexuality relate to masculinity–femininity; homosexual men tend to be more feminine than heterosexual men, and homosexual women tend to be more masculine than heterosexual women.”


In other words, this ‘sex atypicality’ may be advantageous when expressed in heterosexuals.  Do some (perhaps many) females tend to be more attracted to males with certain feminine behavioral traits such as tenderness, considerateness, and kindness?  In this study, the results indeed show that “... psychologically masculine females and feminine men are (a) more likely to be nonheterosexual but (b), when heterosexual, have more opposite-sex sexual partners” (Zietsch et al. 2008).


Another, more general hypothesis for homosexuality is that same-sex attraction never really imposed a significant penalty on fitness in our deep ancestral past, because heterosexual sex was still routinely practiced in spite of it.  There are two very different contexts in which this effect would be expected: 

Bivariate trait space continuum for sexual orientation (Aarssen 2015)
The first obtains from just straightforward bisexuality, i.e. where ancestral sex lives commonly involved a mix of both same-sex and heterosexual activity but in varying proportions (informed in part by genotypic variability) ranging from bisexual with a more dominant opposite-sex attraction, to bisexual with a more dominant same-sex attraction.  But random mating within this mix would also have produced genetic variants that informed strictly homosexual as well as strictly heterosexual orientations — with only the latter of the two strongly favoured by natural selection. 

Nevertheless, despite being strongly disfavoured by natural selection, strict homosexuality would have persisted in low frequency simply because of genetic factors informing same-sex attraction that were inherited from bisexual ancestors.  Under this hypothesis, homosexuality is not really a Darwinian paradox at all; instead it, along with asexuality, were just periodic maladaptive genotypic by-products of ancestral gene transmission.


Most ancestral bisexuals, however, were probably female. Research has shown that men are generally attracted to one sex or the other, whereas women are more likely than men to have a bisexual orientation. According to one hypothesis, a ‘fluid sexuality’ that enabled same-sex sexual behavior in women made it easier for women to raise children together. 


Painting of King Solomon and his wives
by Giovanni Venanzi di Pesaro (1627-1705)
This, according to Kuhle (2013): "… would have been particularly beneficial to ancestral women when their male mates were unable to adequately care, protect, and provide because they were injured, away on prolonged hunts, or preoccupied finding, courting, and mating with other women.  The latter scenario was particularly likely to occur within polygynous mating systems. ...



If so, it is possible that men’s relative lack of aversion to a female mate’s homosexual, rather than heterosexual, affair … and men’s common fantasy of simultaneously mating with multiple women … is an outgrowth of a male psychology designed to promote their mates’ same-sex sexual behavior.”


The latter would have commonly benefitted the offspring of not just bisexual women, but also the men who fathered these offspring, many of whom were often not around to help raise them.  Ironically, therefore, for many of our male ancestors, it was probably better for their own genetic fitness, if their partners were bisexual.
The second context for predicting successful heterosexual practice (and hence gene transmission) — despite the presence of same sex attraction — applies even in the case of strong preference for same-sex encounters, including strict homosexuality.  According to what we might call the ‘failed disfavouring selection’ hypothesis (Aarssen 2015), female homosexuality probably never had widespread opportunity to be strongly disfavoured by natural selection.  This is because, throughout much (probably most) of human history, males were to a large extent in control of the sexual activity and fertility of females.  Many or most women, therefore, were essentially forced — by patriarchal subjugation, socio-cultural expectations, and / or religious imperatives — to mate with men and bear their (frequently many) offspring, regardless of their sexual orientation. [The same would also have been true regardless of the intensity of female sexual impulse (drive)]. 


Accordingly, so called ‘gay genes’ in many of our female ancestors — including those that might have been inherited by their sons as well as their daughters — were never significantly limited in their transmission success to future generations.  And so in this context, the prevalence of homosexuality today is (again) not really a Darwinian paradox at all.

Importantly however, women more than ever are now in control of both their fertility and their sex lives, and their empowerment for this and other basic human rights continues to grow rapidly on a global scale.  For our predecessors, choosing successfully to be a practicing homosexual meant zero gene transmission through direct lineage.  But today this is not necessarily the case, with reproductive technologies for sperm banks and in-vitro fertilization (and perhaps, in the future, human cloning).  But unless the latter become widely practiced as a popular cultural norm, the widespread mating and reproductive freedom for women today means that selection against an exclusively or predominantly lesbian orientation may soon be ramping up (Aarssen & Altman 2006).  If female bisexuality, remains alive and well, however, so also would some homosexuality (because of genetic inheritance from bisexual maternal ancestors).

The above scenario is a good example of how some traits — like homosexuality, the generally weaker sexual impulse in females compared with males, and the child-free culture — rather than a consequence of being favoured by natural selection in the ancestral past, may instead be a consequence of not having been disfavoured by natural selection.


References

Aarssen LW (2015) What Are We? Exploring the Evolutionary Roots of Our Future. Queen’s University, Kingston.

Aarssen LW, Altman S (2006) Explaining below-replacement fertility and increasing childlessness in wealthy countries: Legacy drive and the “transmission competition” hypothesis. Evolutionary Psychology 4: 290-302.

Barash DP (2012) Homo Mysterious: Evolutionary Puzzles of Human Nature. Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Camperio-Ciani A, Corna F, Capiluppi C (2004) Evidence for maternally inherited factors favouring male homosexuality and promoting female fecundity. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Series B: Biological Sciences 271: 2217–2221.

Iemmola F, Camperio-Ciani A (2009) New evidence of genetic factors influencing sexual orientation in men: female fecundity increase in the maternal line. Archives of Sexual Behavior 38: 393–399.

Kuhle BX (2013) Born Both Ways: The alloparenting Hypothesis for sexual fluidity in women. Evolutionary Psychology 11: 304-323.

Ngun TC, Ghahramani N, Sa´nchez FJ, Bocklandt S, Vilain E (2011) The genetics of sex differences in brain and behavior. Frontiers in Neuroendocrinology 32: 227–246.

Sanders AR, Martin ER, Beecham GW, Guo S, Dawood K, Rieger G, Badner JA, Gershon ES, Krishnappa RS, Kolundzija AB, Duan J, Gejman PV, Bailey JM (2015) Genome-wide scan demonstrates significant linkage for male sexual orientation. Psychological Medicine 45: 1379-1388.

Zietscha BP, Morley KI, Shekar SN, Verweij KJH, Keller MC, Macgregor S, Wright MJ, Bailey JM, Martin NG (2008) Genetic factors predisposing to homosexuality may increase mating success in heterosexuals. Evolution and Human Behavior 29: 424–433.

27 comments:

  1. Divya Saxena is hot and sexy Rohini Call Girl available 24/7 for performs with you, Now ... Hi, I am an Independent Call Girls In Rohini for fun - Rohini Escorts.Call at - 09999965857.

    mehrauli escorts service ###
    sarojini nagar escorts service ###
    preet vihar escorts service ###
    vasant vihar escorts service ###
    kirti nagar escorts service ###
    khan market escorts service ###

    ReplyDelete
  2. Top Independent Ahmedabad Escorts are most charming and besides cute with your beginning and end needs. The genuine joy is empowered by each and every girl; just you need to pick without shy.Change yourself with extraordinary foundation with incredible escorts.visit my website :-
    naroda escorts ###
    ghatlodia escorts ###
    vastrapur escorts ###
    asarwa escorts ###
    cg road escorts ###
    jagatpur escorts ###
    sanand escorts ###
    narol escorts ###
    meghani nagar escorts ###

    ReplyDelete




  3. You can surf the varieties of escorts here. Escorts Service in Haridwar In the list of factors to get various people around the world. You can make your evening amazing with this quality Call Girls in Haridwar Every one of our escorts is completely ready to give you personal moments packed with the colour tone of avarice. Check our other services...
    Russian Call Girls in Gurgaon 
    Russian Call Girls in Jaipur
    Call Girls in Aerocity

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi, my Ms.Alisha Are you set to get agreeable for real? At that point call me whenever you call for me and I will come soon or demand you to my level room. The incentive for my administrations is sensible for everybody. Thus, don't miss your likelihood and tome my time for the dusk now. Grown-up (Raipur Escort) A-levels administration with me you will remember for the best time.

    Raipur escorts model
    Model escorts in Raipur
    Raipur escorts agency
    Raipur escorts service
    call girls in raipur
    raipur call girls

    ReplyDelete

  5. While looking for the most reliable provider of Russian escorts Bangalore, you will hardly come across a more reliable and trustworthy party than ours.This is what drags Indian men to hire the escorts from our company, rather than approaching other providers of escort services.visit my website :-
    bangalore escorts ###
    bangalore call girls ###
    banashankari call girls ###
    banaswadi call girls ###
    basavanagudi call girls ###
    basaveshwaranagar call girls ###
    bellandur call girls ###
    benson town call girls ###
    btm layout call girls ###

    ReplyDelete
  6. Ruhhi Dhawan is a Best of pleasant and erotic Escorts in Rohini. Call girl service Rohini, welcomes you to have a wonderful and good experience for real pic person. You can Visit my website and check my profile.
    Rohini Escorts
    independent escort Rohini
    Female escorts in Rohini
    escorts in Rohini
    Rohini Female Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi i am Poonamescorts 100% Real Beautiful and good thinking sizzling most popular Mahipalpur escorts service exclusive high profile Model extraordinary waiting for real pic person. You can Visit my website and check my profile.9873777170
    Mahipalpur escorts
    independent escort Mahipalpur
    female escorts in Mahipalpur
    escorts in Mahipalpur
    Mahipalpur female escorts

    ReplyDelete

  8. Our Chennai Escorts has gathered the best girls from all over the country to make your nights memorable.Each of the agency claims their service to be the best. But in most of the cases, their clients don't get the satisfaction they seek for.visit my website:-
    escorts in poes garden ##
    escorts in taramani ##
    escorts in gopalapuram ##
    escorts in velachery ##
    escorts in anna salai ##
    escorts in mylapore ##
    escorts in koyambedu ##
    escorts in adyar ##
    escorts in besant nagar ##

    ReplyDelete
  9. To meet your dream girl escort yamanisingh.com is the best model girl in Bangalore. We offer Models and high-profile Bangalore escorts at affordable rates.

    independent bangalore escorts
    bangalore escorts agency
    bangalore escorts service
    bangalore escorts model

    ReplyDelete
  10. Meet our sexy babes working as ghaziabad escorts service is one of the Charming well-mannered educated prostitute Profile in ghaziabad.We have more than 90 call girls in ghaziabad

    sarojini nagar escorts |
    govindpuri escorts |
    noida extension escorts |
    greater noida escorts |
    vikas puri escorts |
    karol bagh escorts |

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hello there, I am Shruti Sinha GF and wonderful. Best a genuine Independent Raipur youngster I am so fulfilled you rub along and striptease, besides this, isn't all my differentiation. As strong, I can satisfy a varying assortment of stance and operational break. However, you need extraordinary or just irritating notions, sometime later plan to have drawn in with butt-driven and arousing stroke. Make your aching to absorb from the estimating glass of fulfillment today Whatsapp number 9711199012.

    independent escort Raipur
    Raipur escorts
    female escorts in Raipur
    escorts in Raipur
    Raipur female escorts

    ReplyDelete
  12. Mumbai or surrounding in Mumbai and interested to spend a remarkable night with a hot and beautiful girl then you must hire Mumbai Escorts.There are lots of independent escort professionals as well as escort agencies now available in the market.

    mumbai escorts ||
    mumbai call girls ||
    independent mumbai escorts ||
    vip mumbai escorts ||
    house wife escorts mumbai ||
    female escorts mumbai ||
    russian escorts mumbai ||

    ReplyDelete


  13. Men looking for Female Escorts in Agra usually have a variety of needs that need to be fulfilled. Some want to hire escorts just as a companion, some want them to be their dinner dates or dance floor partners while others may want them to play the role of the sexy girlfriends. Check our other services also..
    Russian Escorts in Agra
    Female Escorts in Faridabad
    Escorts in Faridabad
    Call Girls in Faridabad

    ReplyDelete
  14. In the opinion of our clients, they found our call girls in Bangalore really worthy of their time and money. These beautiful and classy girls can be the best companions for all sorts of ambiances and across all types of needs for companionships.
    Russian Escorts Bangalore ***

    Call Girls Bangalore ***

    Bangalore Escorts ***

    Independent Bangalore Escorts ***

    Escorts Service in Bangalore ***

    Russian Call Girls Bangalore ***

    Bangalore Independent Escorts ***

    Escorts in Bangalore ***

    Female Escorts in Bangalore ***

    ReplyDelete
  15. Once you hire the service of Amazing qualities of Russian escort in Chennai then you will come to know about the different amazing qualities of these call girls.They never disappoint any of their clients in any way.

    chennai escorts ###
    call girls chennai ###
    russian escorts in chennai ###
    chennai escorts service ###
    chennai escorts ###
    chennai escorts ###
    chennai escorts ###

    ReplyDelete
  16. Chandigarh Mehndi designer for Bridal Mehendi Arabic Mehendi, Portriat Mehndi , Rajasthani Mehendi. Call 9888884172.

    Best Mehndi Artist in Chandigarh

    ReplyDelete
  17. We are a leading online marketing agency offering a complete package of internet marketing solutions to help your business grow


    online marketing agency



    ReplyDelete
  18. Contact 9711199171 Ms tinamalik for high class South and North Indian escort girls services.ghaziabad independent escorts, ghaziabad escorts agencies and strip clubs from ghaziabad, India.

    shipra suncity escorts ||-->
    gaur city escorts ||-->
    govindpuram escorts ||-->
    abhay khand escorts ||-->
    niti khand escorts ||-->
    gyan khand escorts ||-->
    hindon residential area escorts ||-->
    nyay khand escorts ||-->

    ReplyDelete
  19. If you want to avail bold service in regard to sexual fantasy, you should hire call girls in Chennai by sure. These call girls are very frank and open minded to their customers.Thus, customers never feel hesitation to share their feelings or expectation when they meet their call girls.

    Visit Here : -
    Chennai escorts ##
    chennai call girls ##
    russian escorts in chennai ##
    chennai escorts service ##
    Chennai escorts
    chennai call girls


    ReplyDelete
  20. While thousands of men displays their priority towards our escort service in Indore agency, over other providers, we feel, you can afford to trust and rely on us.Thus, we are confident that we would be able to do justice to your faith and trust in our agency.visit my website :-
    indore escorts

    call girls indore

    russian escorts in indore

    escorts service in indore




    ReplyDelete

Follow by Email